Keep Victoria Falls Wild
Current Threats
Mosi-oa-Tunya National Park (Zambia)
Observation Wheel [Abandoned proposal, 2020]
Wheel Deal Causes a Spin (2017)
The proposal for a tourism observation wheel was first disclosed to UNESCO in the 2016 State of Conservation reports and described as ‘mimicking the London Eye,’ together with an ambiguous reference to a new hotel within the ‘development zone.’ In response the World Heritage Committee again emphasised the need to submit detailed Environmental and Social Impact Assessments for consideration before authorising significant developments on the ground.
“The proposed construction of a Ferris wheel within the high ecologically sensitive zone of the Eastern Cataract as well as the proposed hotel and recreational facilities in the property are of great concern due to their potential significant impacts on the OUV of the property, especially under criterion (vii). The draft JIMP prescribes permitted and prohibited activities and facilities within specific zones, and a Ferris wheel would clearly be incompatible. Regrettably, no response was received from the State Parties regarding the utilization of Cataract Island for tourism.
“For all of these projects, it is recommended that the Committee request the State Parties to clarify their exact locations and to undertake rigorous ESIAs, including specific assessment of impacts on OUV in line with IUCN’s World Heritage Advice Note on Environmental Assessment, and to ensure that no decision is taken that may be difficult to reverse and before these ESIAs have been provided to the World Heritage Centre for consideration by IUCN...
“In view of the proposed tourism developments, it is also recommended that the Committee request the State Parties to complete the sustainable tourism strategy currently underway, as well as the sustainable financing/business plan previously requested by the Committee.” (UNESCO, 2017)
The World Heritage Committee recorded:.
“Noting with significant concern that construction of a Ferris wheel is proposed within a high ecologically sensitive zone of the Eastern Cataract inside the property, which would be incompatible with the permitted infrastructural development as prescribed in the JIMP, and which will likely have a significant detrimental impact on the OUV of the property, urges the State Parties to not permit the project.” (World Heritage Committee, 2017)
Wheel Deal Takes Another Spin (2017)
In early November 2017 it emerged that a Chinese investor, Ju Wenbin (CEO of China-Africa Cotton Development Limited), had apparently secured an agreement at government level to develop an observation viewing wheel overlooking the Eastern Cataract. The investor had reportedly secured the purchase of land currently occupied by the curio traders market at the Falls, causing uproar among traders (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 4th November 2017).
Representatives of the Zimbabwe National Parks and Wildlife Management were quoted a threatening ‘tourism war’ over the plans, which clearly breached UNESCO World Heritage Site development guidelines, whilst Livingstone operators and residents also expressed similar concerns over the project (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 13th November 2017).
In their 2018 and 2019 reports Zambian officials reported that there were no developments in relation to the proposal.
“The State Party took note of the concern raised with respect to the proposed Ferris Wheel in the World Heritage Site. The State Parties would like to report that there are no developments on the ground and will continue to update the committee should there be any developments.” (State Parties, 2018, p.4-5)
“To date, there has been no on-ground development of the proposed Ferris wheel on Eastern Cataract, or any other tourism infrastructure, and the World Heritage Committee will be kept informed.” (UNESCO, 2019)
Wheel Deal Comes Round Again (2020)
News reports from June 2020 indicated that ZESCO had sold land from within its infrastructure support site located close to the Victoria Falls Power Station and within the Mosi-oa-Tunya National Park and UNESCO World Heritage Site.
“ZESCO has sold land at the Victoria Falls to Chinese national Ju Wenbin for the construction of a Ferris Wheel... In January 2017 Chief Mukuni fought with success attempts by State House to offer Ju Wenbin the curio market at the Victoria Falls to erect a Spin-Sational Ferris Wheel. However, the National Heritage Conservation Commission (NHCC) has warned that the said land being within the Victoria Falls World Heritage Site (VFWHS) cannot have a construction of the proposed Ferris Wheel under UNESCO guidelines.” (Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs, 17th June 2020)
The 44th session of the UNESCO World Heritage Committee, originally planned for 2020 but postponed due to the pandemic, recorded:
“On 24th June 2020, the World Heritage Centre also requested comments from the State Party concerning the sale of land for construction of a Ferris wheel within the property. No specific response has been received from the State Parties in relation to the Ferris wheel proposal at the time writing.” (UNESCO, 2021)
The proposals appear to have subseqnetly been abandoned.
References
Links to external sites or pdf downloads, open in a new window.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (4th November 2017) Zambia sells land near Victoria Falls for Chinese to erect observation ferris wheel.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (7th November 2017) Zim to oppose Zambia’s plan for a spin wheel at Vic Falls.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (13th November 2017) Livingstone tour operators oppose spin wheel project at Vic Falls.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (31st May 2020) Over 20 L/stone families face eviction from Zesco houses.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (6th June 2020) State House is giving in to Chinese over Vic Falls site – Mukuni.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (17th June 2020) Zesco sells Vic Falls land for proposed tourism ferris wheel development.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (21st June 2020) Chief Mukuni claims abuse of office by Zesco in relation to potential tourism development.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (13th July 2020) Zambia sells part of Victoria Falls land to China.
Victoria Falls Bits and Blogs (17th August 2020) Wheel Deal Paints a Picture.